Hedge Fund Review
Career Center Jobs and Career Management in the Financial Markets, Banking & Finance Career Center
  Job Seekers Sign in / Register Recruiter's Sign-in

TOP STORIES

MBAs first to get dumped

COMMENTS

Don't you hate the fact that I can still choose to leave banking and go find an equally stimulating six figure job elsewhere?  Read all comments »

The associate intakes of 2006 and 2007 are being decimated, according to both bankers and the recruiters who are left to pick up the pieces. So what does an MBA with big debts and only one year’s banking experience do? Private equity, boutiques, or strategy consulting seem to be the answer.

“Most of the people who’ve gone from the team are MBAs who joined at the junior associate level,” says a VP at one US bank. “Unfortunately, it just makes sense to get rid of them – they have a limited amount of banking experience and they’re relatively expensive. They’re getting hit particularly hard.”

Recruiters confirm that a disproportionate number of recent MBAs are coming through their doors. “We’re getting a lot of MBAs coming to us,” says Katherine Howe at recruitment firm KHG Partners. “They’re either last year’s banking intake, or the intake of summer 2006.”

Faced with the choice of dumping a recently hired MBA or an analyst who’s been nurtured at a bank for several years, Logan Naidu of recruiters The Cornell Partnership, says banks are typically going for the former option. “MBAs are as expensive as third-year analysts, but analysts have spent three years with the firm and know how a deal is put together.”

Business schools are a brake on the MBA purge, however. If too many of their alumni are ejected, banks get a bad reputation on campus at the major business schools, which they are anxious to avoid, says Howe: “If you hire a load of MBAs from a top business school and treat them all appallingly, that school might be less inclined to allow you to recruit on campus in the future.”

As a result, she says some banks are now letting go of high performing third-year analysts rather than reneging on offers made to MBAs who are joining this year.

MBAs who are dumped by banks do have other options. “The alternatives are boutiques, private equity, corporates, or strategy consulting, depending on experience and background,” says Naidu.

COMMENTS

Steven, Sales & Marketing,  Tue 15 Jul 08

Did anyone say Mediocre But Arrogant???
Performance is usually a driver in difficult economic times.

Add your comment »

Red Shoes, HR & Recruitment,  Tue 15 Jul 08

Performance AND whether your face still fits or not....

Add your comment »

Henry, FX & Money Markets,  Tue 15 Jul 08

MBAs. What an absolute waste of 2 years whilst your peers are earning 6 figures climbing the ladder further.

Add your comment »

MBA, Risk Management,  Tue 15 Jul 08

Hmmm, why do MBAs have more options then?

Add your comment »

Not MBA, Investment Banking / M & A,  Tue 15 Jul 08

Not finance it seems...

Add your comment »

Gio, Investment Banking / M & A,  Tue 15 Jul 08

The artikel is right.. I know for fact that people with MBA aren't  necessarly more clever than non MBA people. Infact, non MBA, they deliver better results.. !

Add your comment »

M, Hedge Funds,  Tue 15 Jul 08

Also, not all MBA programs are 2 years.  International options are often the best bet, as many of the top programs such as INSEAD are only essentially 10 months.

Add your comment »

amod, Hedge Funds,  Tue 15 Jul 08

this guy in my MBA section smelled really bad- he was from India like me. Nice guy but damn did he smell........

Add your comment »

Doug, Compliance / Legal,  Tue 15 Jul 08

Having an MBA is not a question of being smart or not, nor being better than someone who has none - hello people! ....did a technical degree, and after a few years went for the MBA while working at the very same time, studying in the weekends & having no real life for more than 2 years. Is there a difference now ? You betchya - you may fire me tomorrow (which happened to me while at CS), yet the options are much wider once on the free market again....within days I was called by several headhunters for several different positions and roles ....as opposed to only one particular job in one specific area if I still had my IT degree ...got then a new job within days in a different vertical, had nothing to do with what I had to do with CS. This is possible not because an MBA is smarter (dah), nor more experienced, but rather because an MBA has the chance (or not) to have the right tools and foundation to a specific problem, and then go from there......just like every graduate of any degree, not everyone is good at it, kind of annoying to explain thaagain and again. The best investment I ever did in my life, not even worth the 2 years salary that folks out there may miss by going for it.

Add your comment »

Roger, Capital Markets,  Tue 15 Jul 08

Many MBAs are those that didn't get into a good IB job after their undergrad so it goes without saying that they are not the best candiates and perhaps should be the first ones to go.

Unless you have MBA from Wharton or Harvard that is different of course

Add your comment »
< Prev   1, 2, 3, 4   Next >

ADD YOUR COMMENT

* Mandatory fields
Your name
Your field
Your Comment*
You have 1200 characters left
Image verification* ( What is this? )
Enter the code shown below or Sign in / Register to skip this step.
Disclaimer: All comments must adhere to eFinancialCareers Ltd’s Add your comment rules.
To complain about a comment, please email editor@efinancialcareers.com.
© Incisive Media Ltd. 2007
Incisive Media Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, is a company registered in the United Kingdom with company registration number 04038503