Hedge Fund Review
Career Center Jobs and Career Management in the Financial Markets, Banking & Finance Career Center
  Job Seekers Sign in / Register Recruiter's Sign-in

ADVICE

Guest comment: the legal approach to redundancy

COMMENTS

No employer likes to find out that you have taken legal action in your past and you will find yourself in the unenviable position of never getting beyond 2nd interview stage anywhere.  Read all comments »

Think you might be made redundant? Now's the time to start saving those emails, says employment lawyer Elaine Aarons.

Everyone in the City knows that economic woes lead to redundancies and the banking sector is being particularly hard hit in the current downturn.The latest figures from the Centre for Economics and Business Research suggest that up to 10,000 jobs could be lost in the City this year alone.

But in every round of redundancies, a significant percentage of employees are reluctant to just sign on the dotted line and accept their redundancy offer, especially if they feel their dismissal is unfair or unjustified.

First steps

If you are concerned about redundancy, the best precautionary measure you can take is to make careful notes of all conversations with your employer. It goes without saying that you should save all relevant e-mails or letters too. Amassing evidence is crucial.

This advice particularly applies to high achievers. Counter-intuitively, we are currently seeing some banks making their high fliers redundant. Speculation is that this way clients can be shared out amongst fewer players, thereby increasing profitability.

The first formal sign that you may be facing redundancy will be receiving an ‘at risk’ letter from your employer. Redundancy is not supposed to be a definite outcome on receiving such a letter, but it usually is.

In such correspondence, the employer typically explains that they are looking to deploy the ‘at risk’ employee to another department. As many banks have moved towards headcount freezes in the last few weeks, redeployment is not likely.

During and after a dismissal

Employers seem to be adhering more rigidly to proper dismissal procedures now, compared to during the last recession in the 1990s. It will thus be harder to bring a claim based on a procedural mistake, as fewer mistakes are being made.

However, this is not to say that unfair dismissals do not occur – employees are often made redundant in unfair or unjustified circumstances, even if the dismissal procedures are followed.

If you feel that you have been made redundant unfairly, you should ask to see the redundancy criteria that have been applied, and how individuals were selected for redundancy. Other than the counter-intuitive example of high fliers being made redundant cited above, we are seeing evidence of pregnant employees, or those returning from parental or sick leave, being made redundant. If you are made redundant in such circumstances, you may well have a claim for discrimination as well as unfair dismissal. Unfair dismissal claims are capped (currently at £63k). Discrimination claims, which are uncapped, can therefore be more valuable.

Making a claim

If you do feel that you have been unfairly made redundant, you should look into obtaining legal advice. It is likely that your claim will be settled by your employer, particularly if they are facing other similar claims. A good lawyer will be able to maximise the settlement you receive.

A word of warning though: steel yourself for a fight before making any claim. Whilst it is unlikely that your claim will go to a full employment tribunal, you are likely to have to go through either an appeal or grievance procedure, which is never pleasant. Allegations of underperformance are standard fare in the current climate and you will feel on the defensive when you want to be on the attack. You should be absolutely certain of your motives and objectives before seeking a legal solution, but there is no doubt that those who are tenacious do best.

Elaine Aarons is a partner in the employment team at international law firm Withers LLP. She specialises in acting for senior executives.

COMMENTS

Sam, Investment Banking / M & A,  Sat 05 Apr 08

Here are some of sites on employment law, which are useful when writing your grievance.

GENERAL EMPLOYMENT LAW
http://www.stripessolicitors.co.uk/pages/unfair_dismissal.html
http://www.bbc.co.uk/consumer/guides_to/employment_index.shtml

WORK RELATED STRESS (caused by bullying etc):
http://www.lhc.org.uk/members/pubs/books/hl/hl03_07.htm

Add your comment »

Jane,  Sat 05 Apr 08

Thanks, Mary - consider yourself invited to the launch!  Early stages of discussions with publisher currently, but looking very promising.  One thing is for sure - it won't be dull, or doomladen.  The most useful attribute you can bring to this situation is a good sense of humour...

Add your comment »

Mary,  Mon 07 Apr 08

Hi Jane, I’m sure you will do very well with your book. Sometimes having a negative experience can motivate you to do great things. I studied law at university before going into banking, which has been a great asset in my fight against my Swiss employer. It is shocking how badly I have been treated by them, but I am coming to realise none of it is personal. I’m currently thinking of retraining as an employment lawyer to raise awareness of the way banks abuse their dominant bargaining power. It is true that many people fear they will never work again in the City if they challenge their employer. However, it would be interesting to see how uneasy people would be if they knew the full extent of the abuse of the law by their bank. When people see high profile cases in the papers, it is easy to dismiss it as an individual who simply couldn’t cope with the pressures of banking. In reality it is just the tip of the iceberg, compromise agreements often hide the facts of the most shocking cases. I think there is definitely a market for your book. It is important that employees are equipped to protect themselves from the underhand tactics many of these banks employ to get rid of staff

Add your comment »

Jane,  Mon 07 Apr 08

Mary, I completely agree with you.  It does sound as though your battle is almost identical to ours - and one of my primary motivations to keep taking the fight to the bullies was that none of it was necessary:  a shred of decency and the ability to acknowledge when wrongdoing has happened, and all of this would have been resolved years ago.  I won't support the idea that bullies and cheats should be allowed to win just because they're big and have infinite resources at their disposal.  I haven't behaved perfectly throughout our battle - but I know I haven't lied to anyone, or done anything other than to protect my husband's reputation and try to establish the truth.  The villains of the piece just hand the problem over to HR and the legal department - and they are 100% complicit in unethical and unlawful behaviour.  There should be penalties...  I applaud your ambitions to train as an employment lawyer - the world needs more lawyers motivated by ethics and decency than by billable hours.  Mary, if you email the editor of eFinancialCareers with your contact details, she can pass them onto me (off the site so your identity is protected). We could swap war stories?

Add your comment »

Anonymous, Capital Markets,  Mon 07 Apr 08

I was bullied and harassed at a US bank. If you want to get payment you have to move first, make sure you have legal insurance, you can get £50k to £100k on your home insurance. Then make notes, keep a diary. Finally submit a grievance Before they tank you. Grievance procedure will make a banana republic proud..however, then you can resign and get your legal insurance lawyer involved. Legal insurance wont cover a £400/hr lawyer but it will half that...or you could get a younger cheaper smart lawyer where the insurance covers their entire fee. Then you just sit there, (you still get stressed) and wait for the cheque. You do need a lawyer to guide you through the grievance procedure...however think outside London. There are lawyers in the West country who are just as good, but dont have to pay London rent...result, the fees for a senior partner are £100 - £150 /hr cheaper. Even £50/hr cheaper adds up.
Good luck. I'm all for firing weak performers, but people who bully juniors due to their own poor performance need to be taken to Court and ripped apart. Legal insurance will give you the upper cap fee to do this. Dont rely on HR, they take the commerical view. Senior $$ vs junior -$$

Add your comment »

ex-cap mkts, Hedge Funds,  Thu 10 Apr 08

Don't believe all the people who claim that if you submit a grievance your career is over. This is the usual scare tactic, and oh does work well. Instead, first speak to your bully or manager and takes notes. With dictaphones being so cheap and small, I would seriously consider keeping one on you at all times to record your manager's bullying on tape.
I kept detailed notes of dates and times when i was harassed. Of course the grievance procedure was a sham, but with the weight of eveidence I had, my former bank settled prior to court and I also ensured everyone I worked for signed gagging orders. I moved into a HF (this was late 2006, before the mkts turned) and have never looked back. Never let a bullying manager walk over you, they do so because they feel threatened by you.
If you think you'll just wait it out, don't! Bullying will affect your entire life, you go home and take it out on your gf/wife/friends and you will start to hate yourself. Its very hard but stand up for yourself. Like the Dr.Pepper add...what's the worst that can happen...? Banking isn't that great; get other interests (part-time law course?), then you won't be afraid should you decide to walk away.

Add your comment »

Jane,  Fri 11 Apr 08

Like your style ex cap.mkts Hedge Funds...if nothing else, you'll have an accurate record of the bullying/empty promises/stellar-appraisal-subsequently-denied.  Slight word of caution: as far as I am aware, recordings made without the knowledge/consent of all parties concerned are not admissible evidence in court (one of the reasons that electronic bugging is such a dubious area of surveillance).  Of course, this doesn't stop you using such recordings to blow the bad guys out of the water before you get in front of a judge.  But doesn't the fact that you're even thinking this way demonstrate that the trust relationship with your employer is totally broken?  Another black mark against firms that proclaim that they 'value their employees as their greatest asset'.  Yeah right.

Add your comment »

Julie, Investment Banking / M & A,  Sat 12 Apr 08

It’s true many employers do try to scare you off by saying you’ll never get another job in the City if you make a complaint. However, if your grievance is on the grounds of discrimination, such a threat is an act of victimisation under the legislation and actionable. No prospective employer should be discriminating against a job seeker on this basis either. It’s shocking that people think it is acceptable to openly make such unlawful comments!

Add your comment »

ex-cap mkts, Hedge Funds,  Mon 14 Apr 08

Thanks Jane! I do agree that electronic bugging has side issues attached, however the grievance process is not a Court and you can write whatever you like in the letter. You will probably scare your employer enough for them to privately settle with you. I was actually offered quite a large amount of money to not go through the appeal stage of the grievance, but I wanted to see my manager in Court. Though I hardly showed it, the bullying I endured really affected me and I needed private CBT therapy to fully recover. There was no way I was going to let this guy get away with it. Workplace bullying is inlike any other form of harassment. You cannot walk away, and unlike school you can't even punch your bully (of course my manager was a classic short ar5e...as they probably all are). I implore anyone who is being bullied to stand up for yourself, by not doing so you will only hurt yourself long term. Life is funny, only a few weeks back my ex-manager had an interview at the HF i worked for...poor guy was another redundant trader looking for a job. Lets just say he didnt get the job, and his interview with me was well interesting...and quite fun! Unfortunately I didn't punch him...

Add your comment »

Julie, Investment Banking / M & A,  Mon 14 Apr 08

Dear ex-cap mkts, I have a great deal of admiration for you. I also understand the impact work place bullying can have on your health longer term if you don't stand up for yourself. Great to hear you're doing well in your new career!

Add your comment »
< Prev   1, 2, 3, 4, 5   Next >

ADD YOUR COMMENT

* Mandatory fields
Your name
Your field
Your Comment*
You have 1200 characters left
Image verification* ( What is this? )
Enter the code shown below or Sign in / Register to skip this step.
Disclaimer: All comments must adhere to eFinancialCareers Ltd’s Add your comment rules.
To complain about a comment, please email editor@efinancialcareers.com.
© Incisive Media Ltd. 2007
Incisive Media Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, is a company registered in the United Kingdom with company registration number 04038503